To choose a Florida probate attorney, focus on three things: relevant courtroom and administration experience in the county where the estate will be probated, a clear and written fee arrangement, and demonstrated familiarity with the Florida Probate Code (Chapters 731 through 735, Florida Statutes). The right lawyer is one who has handled estates similar to yours, communicates plainly about timeline and cost, and is admitted in good standing with The Florida Bar.
That sounds simple. In practice, families discover that “a lawyer who does wills” and “a lawyer who litigates a contested estate before a probate judge” are not the same animal. I have spent years moving cases from the guardianship side into probate after a ward passes, and the gap between the right counsel and the merely available one shows up fast: in missed deadlines, in fees that balloon, and in heirs who stop speaking to each other. This guide walks through what actually matters when you hire.
Understand What Kind of Probate You Actually Have
Before you interview anyone, get clear on the type of proceeding in front of you. Florida law recognizes several paths, and the lawyer you want depends heavily on which one applies.
- Formal administration under Chapter 733 — the standard process for most estates, requiring a personal representative, notice to creditors, and court oversight.
- Summary administration under Chapter 735 — available when the estate’s value (less exempt property) does not exceed $75,000, or when the decedent has been dead more than two years.
- Disposition without administration — a narrow path for very small estates where assets do not exceed final expenses and exempt property.
- Ancillary administration — for a decedent who lived elsewhere but owned Florida property, common when a New York resident dies owning a Florida condo.
The reason this matters for hiring is straightforward. A clean summary administration is a paperwork exercise; you do not need a litigator. A contested formal administration with a will challenge, a fight over who serves as personal representative, or a guardianship that bled into the estate is a different undertaking entirely. Ask the lawyer point-blank which category they think your matter falls into and why. If they cannot answer that on a first call, keep looking.
Verify Credentials Before You Verify Anything Else
Florida requires that the attorney representing a personal representative be a member in good standing of The Florida Bar. Use the Bar’s online directory to confirm three facts: active status, no recent disciplinary history, and how long the attorney has actually been practicing. A clean record is the floor, not the ceiling.
Look for Genuine Probate Concentration
Plenty of general-practice lawyers will take a probate file. What you want is someone for whom estate administration is a core part of the practice, not a once-a-year favor. The Florida Bar offers board certification in Wills, Trusts and Estates; certification is not mandatory and many excellent practitioners are not certified, but it is a meaningful signal of focus when present. Membership in the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section of the Bar is another good sign.
Confirm County-Level Experience
Probate is administered at the circuit court level, county by county, and local practice varies more than newcomers expect. The way a Miami-Dade judge handles a contested petition for administration is not identical to Palm Beach or Broward. An attorney who regularly appears before the clerk and judges in your county knows the local filing quirks, the personalities, and the unwritten rhythms. Ask: “How many estates have you administered in this specific county in the last two years?”
Get the Fee Structure in Writing — and Understand It
This is where families get surprised, so slow down here. Florida Statute 733.6171 sets out a statutory fee schedule for attorneys representing the personal representative in formal administration. The statute treats certain percentages of the estate’s compensable value as presumed reasonable — for example, a tiered schedule that begins at $1,500 for estates up to $40,000 and scales up from there. These are presumptions, not mandates.
You and the attorney can agree to a different arrangement, and you should always ask which model they propose:
- Statutory percentage — predictable but can be expensive on a large, simple estate.
- Hourly billing — often fairer for straightforward estates with few assets but high gross value, like a single paid-off home.
- Flat fee — increasingly common for summary administrations and uncontested formal ones.
The statute also requires the attorney to disclose, in writing, that the fee is not set by law and is negotiable. If a lawyer glosses over that disclosure or pressures you toward the percentage method without explaining the alternatives, treat it as a warning sign. Ask separately about extraordinary fees — will contests, tax work, and litigation are billed on top of the basic administration fee under the statute, and you want to know that before, not after.
Probe Their Experience With Contested and Transitional Matters
Estates rarely arrive tidy. The hardest ones I see come out of a prior guardianship — an aging relative was placed under a guardian, family members fought over control or accounting during the guardianship, and then the ward dies and all of that unresolved tension pours straight into probate. The personal representative inherits not just assets but grievances, and sometimes a half-finished accounting that a guardian never closed out.
If your situation has any of that history, you need a lawyer who has lived in the seam between Chapter 744 guardianship and Chapter 733 probate. Ask whether they have handled the wind-down of a guardianship into an estate, how they treat the final guardianship accounting, and whether they have litigated breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims that carry over after death. A pure transactional probate lawyer may not be equipped for that fight.
Even outside the guardianship context, ask about the contested scenarios that show up most often: petitions to remove a personal representative, objections to a will’s validity on grounds of undue influence or lack of capacity, and disputes over the elective share a surviving spouse is entitled to under Florida law. You are not hoping for a fight, but you want to know your lawyer could handle one.
Out-of-State Estates and Ancillary Probate
Many Florida estates involve people whose roots are elsewhere — a New York family with a Florida vacation home is a classic example. If your loved one lived in New York and owned Florida real estate, you may face ancillary administration here while the primary estate is handled up north. In that situation, coordination between counsel in both states matters enormously.
A firm with a footprint in both jurisdictions can spare you the cost and confusion of two disconnected legal teams. If the main estate sits in New York, it helps to understand how a runs in parallel with the Florida ancillary case, because the order of operations affects timing and creditor claims. It is also worth learning that New York, like Florida, has more than one track — the same way Florida distinguishes formal from summary administration, there are depending on the estate’s size and whether a will exists. For the Florida side of a cross-border matter, a dedicated Florida probate practice can manage the ancillary filing while the home-state attorney drives the primary administration.
Interview Questions That Separate Good Counsel From the Rest
Treat the consultation as an interview — because it is. Bring the death certificate, the original will if you have it, and a rough list of assets. Then work through questions like these:
- Who at the firm will actually handle my file day to day — you, an associate, or a paralegal?
- What is a realistic timeline for an estate like mine, start to closing?
- How do you communicate, and how quickly do you return calls and emails?
- What could go wrong here, and how would you respond if it did?
- Can you give me a written fee agreement with the statutory disclosure included?
Watch how they answer as much as what they answer. A seasoned probate attorney will give you a candid range and name the risks rather than promising a frictionless process. Anyone guaranteeing a fast, cheap, no-conflict result on a complicated estate is selling something.
Watch for These Warning Signs
Some red flags are loud, others quiet. Be cautious if a lawyer cannot tell you which type of administration applies, refuses to put fees in writing, treats the statutory fee disclosure as a formality, has no recent county experience, or is dismissive when you describe family conflict. Equally telling is the firm where you can never reach the attorney and a rotating cast of staff handles your questions. Probate runs on deadlines — creditor claim periods, inventory filings, accountings — and a firm that goes dark will cost you both time and money.
Putting It Together
Choosing a Florida probate attorney is less about finding the most famous name and more about matching the lawyer to the matter. A summary administration needs efficiency and a fair flat fee. A contested estate emerging from a fractured guardianship needs a litigator who understands fiduciary duty and the Probate Code in equal measure. A cross-border estate needs coordination across state lines. Once you know which problem you actually have, the right questions — and the right lawyer — come into focus.
If you are just beginning, it helps to understand the documents at the foundation of any estate; our overview of wills under Florida law is a good starting point, and our Florida probate process guide walks through what to expect after a loved one passes. When you are ready to talk through your specific situation, reach out for a consultation and bring the documents listed above.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a probate attorney cost in Florida?
Florida Statute 733.6171 sets a presumptively reasonable fee schedule based on the estate’s compensable value, starting around $1,500 for estates up to $40,000 and scaling up by tiers. However, the fee is negotiable by law — attorneys must disclose this in writing — and many will offer hourly or flat-fee arrangements that are cheaper for simple estates. Extraordinary services like will contests or tax work are billed separately.
Do I need a lawyer for probate in Florida?
In most formal administrations, yes. Florida law generally requires the personal representative to be represented by a Florida Bar attorney, except where the personal representative is the sole interested person. Summary administration and disposition without administration can sometimes be handled with limited or no counsel, but even then a brief attorney review helps avoid filing errors.
What is the difference between formal and summary administration in Florida?
Formal administration under Chapter 733 is the full court-supervised process with a personal representative and creditor notice, used for most estates. Summary administration under Chapter 735 is a faster, lighter process available when the estate’s value (less exempt property) is $75,000 or under, or when the person has been deceased more than two years.
How long does probate take in Florida?
A straightforward summary administration can close in a few weeks to a couple of months. A formal administration typically runs several months to over a year, largely because the creditor claim period and required filings take time. Contested estates — will challenges, fiduciary disputes, or matters carried over from a prior guardianship — can take considerably longer.
Can a New York attorney handle my Florida probate?
A New York attorney cannot independently administer a Florida estate, but the two often work together. When a non-Florida resident dies owning Florida property, an ancillary administration is opened in Florida alongside the primary estate in the home state. A firm with offices or coordinating counsel in both states can manage this cross-border process efficiently.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.